It looked awful. I wanted to paint over it.

This week, I left the studio feeling ashamed of a painting.

That’s a strong word to use about something I’ve made, but it’s the right one and I bet you recognise the feeling. I looked at what I’d done and felt embarrassed that, after all these years of painting, I could still make something quite so awful.

And what’s worse is that I’d spent all day doing it. You may have seen this painting before when it was at this stage.

 
 

It’s of myself and my brother riding on bumper cars at the seaside. We are 7 and 5 years old. These bumper cars were my brother’s favourite thing in the whole world and I wanted to capture that feeling of joy but also create the sense of a memory rather than something happening recently.

I couldn’t get it right. The colours were not working and I decided to make a big move (this is what I usually do when things are not going well — just do something so big that it is a catalyst. Either the painting gets a lot better or it gets so bad that I have to do something to fix it).

Since these paintings are about memory, I thought cool blues and greens might suggest something slightly distant and out of reach.It seemed like a good idea, but unfortunately, I didn’t get as far as the greens because the blues looked so awful.

The whole thing became cold and chilly. Looking at it actually made me shiver, which was quite an achievement given that I was painting a happy memory.

And somewhere along the way, I lost my brother’s face. In its place, I painted something so rudimentary and ugly that I could hardly bear to look at it.

 
 

So that was my day. Hours spent turning a reasonable painting into something I didn’t even want to have in the room.

I know this happens. I’ve been painting long enough to know that things can go backwards, sometimes quite dramatically. I’ve encouraged enough other people through their own painting disasters to know what I would say to someone else.

But knowing all that didn’t stop me feeling thoroughly miserable about my own.

The next day, I briefly considered covering the whole thing in white paint and starting again. But this is where my teaching experience comes in handy — I remembered what I would say to you. I would say ‘you have not ruined it, you have simply not gone far enough. Step back, look at what’s wrong, and start fixing it.’

So I did. I brought warmth into the figures while keeping some of the blue. I began to bring the face back although it still needs more work. And I started to break up those large bulky bumper car shapes.

 
 

The painting still needs work, but I think it’s heading for the home straight. The base palette feels right now, and I have a much clearer sense of where I’m going. I want to refine the boy's face, develop the hands, and bring back a few spots of bright colours. I'm excited to get to work on it.

What interests me is how different those two days felt.

On the first day, I thought I’d wasted my time. Worse, I felt ashamed. On the second, the very things I hated helped me make decisions. The coldness told me to bring in warmth. The solidity reminded me to let parts disappear.

The feeling of shame was absolutely useless to me. It did not help at all. And in fact, I had nothing to feel bad about, because the decisions I had made turned out to be the right ones. Yes they made the painting worse, but they also gave me a direction.

Without the hideous blue stage, I wouldn’t have brought in the peach. Without the too solid shapes, I wouldn’t have realised I needed more disruption.

We so often stop at the feeling of shame. We make something we dislike and take it as evidence that we aren’t very good at this, or that we’ve wasted the little time we had available. It’s hard to come back with any curiosity when we’ve already decided the whole thing says something terrible about us.

If that’s you, I hope my experience will help you the next time this happens. Instead of feeling that sense of creeping shame when you look at the terrible painting, try putting that feeling aside and just reacting to what’s in front of you. Too loud? Quieten some things down. Too dark? Add some lights. Wrong colour palette? Change it.

Your move might not fix the issue but it will definitely give you something else to respond to and that’s all we ever need — something to spark the next move.

I’m so pleased I didn’t paint over this. I was right that the painting looked awful, but I was wrong about the day being wasted. Those awful moves were exactly what led me to where I am now :)

Next
Next

What's the Point?